Monday, February 10, 2014

Why are the people in the U.S. so blase' about Privacy?

So this was the question I received today about privacy: "Why are people in the U.S. so blase' about privacy?"

Frankly, my dear, I don't know.

I do have some theories that my mind is sorting through as I write - and if you have some thoughts (yes, you, the one person who is reading this), please do write me and let me know your opinion.

First, I do not think it is related to the fact that we do not have an explicit right to privacy guaranteed to us in the U.S. Constitution. However, I do think it is related to what rights we are guaranteed and how those rights have been enforced over the years. Most importantly, I think the freedom of speech as personified through the freedom of the press has been a huge factor in how blase' we are about privacy. As citizens, we are allowed to say what we want to say (in general), do what we want to do (shy of breaking laws), move where we want to move, live how we want to live, love as we desire - and act on that love. Freedom of speech includes our actions, our apparel, and our writings. And this freedom comes with a price - that we are ever so willing to pay - the lack of privacy.

Next, the American dream reinforces the lack of privacy. To achieve our dreams - or at least for those ridiculously mega-rich people to achieve their dreams, they take chances and go where no one has gone before, with information, brazenness, and wild willingness to use any tools at their disposal. Information is mostly free and can be used in ways that the average person would find mind-boggling.

Additionally, most Americans have not suffered atrocious crimes and deeply personal invasions like countries with currently strong privacy laws have in the past - where thousands of people were tortured and killed based on information, like their race, religion, or even just their name.

Thus on one hand, we see benefits in the freedom of information and on the other hand, we see no penalties in the misuse of information. I have often been told that if a company treats personal information with the respect other nations require, the company would lose its competitive edge. So what would motivate us to care? When I posted previously questioning why we are not outraged at the NSA, one of the responses I got was that once the PATRIOT ACT was enacted, any person who read it or watched the news knew that we now had no right to privacy. In a way, I agree. Not enough people were outraged then - and you cannot let the exploding holes in the dam go unnoticed and then complain about a flooded home.

We need a fundamental shift in our thinking. Information is a power tool. And it can be dangerous in the wrong hands. It can be dangerous in the right hands - if those are not your hands holding your own information. We need to be stingy. For example, unless you are on a government health insurance program or workers' comp, your doctor does not need your social security number. Such a simple thing. But try telling your doctor he/she does not need it and they freak out - they are so used to getting it, they just want to fill the blank. So I just pretend not to know it. "Ooops sorry. Don't carry the card either, but I'll really try to remember to bring it the next time." Not.


No comments:

Post a Comment